Julie and Julia: What Julia Child Has to Teach Women Students Today and What Julie Had to Teach Me

I had the good fortune of seeing the movie Julie and Julia this past weekend and I loved it, as did the rest of the audience! Everyone clapped after many of the scenes—something which rarely happens in the movies. The movie is based on the true stories of the famous, American-French chef Julia Child (played by Meryl Streep) and a New York writer named Julie who decides to cook all of Julia’s recipes in a year and to blog about it daily.

Julia Child broke into the elite and all male French culinary school, Le Cordon Bleu, via sheer persistence.  In the movie, Julia watches on her first day as her fellow classmates expertly and rapidly chop onions while she lags behind. The instructor tutors her on proper knife technique, while the others watch and no doubt question her skills.  In the next scene we see Julia’s husband come home that evening to find his wife chopping a mound of what must be 30 to 40 onions. The scene is hilarious as they are both crying from all the chopped onions, and the message is clear—Julia is going to do whatever it takes to succeed at Le Cordon Bleu.  The very next day in class she chops the onions expertly and is the first to finish, thereby gaining the respect of her fellow male students and instructor.

However, there is one other obstacle to Julia’s success at the Cordon Bleu school of cooking and guess what? It’s a woman, the owner of the school. She is reluctant to let Julia in the school in the first place and sets her up to fail by placing her in an advanced professional class when Julia complains about being in a beginning all female class that is extremely elementary. She refuses to let Julia take the test she needs to receive her diploma. Julia must ultimately reference her friendship with the American Ambassador in order to take the test (her husband is a diplomat). She is given a test clearly designed for her to fail; forcing her to request another opportunity to take the exam.

This touches on a little discussed subject—one that is still relevant today.  What about when women undermine other women? Well this does happen, especially when a woman is one of very few. Sometimes the pioneer woman doesn’t want other women to succeed. Why? This phenomenon–referred to as “tokenism” in the field of sociology—happens when someone is a minority and wants to fit in with the majority. Sometimes the way a person tries to accomplish this is by trying to appear more like the majority than the majority group themselves. Clearly it must have been quite rare at that time for a woman to own an elite male culinary school–she must have herself struggled to be in this position–and she did not want to jeopardize this.

An excellent video on tokenism that I have used in the training I do for supervisors on how to integrate women into a male-dominated workplace is The Tale of X and O.  The Xs are the insiders and the Os are the outsiders. There are many “ahas” that go off for both men and women when I show it.

Ok, so what did I learn from Julie? I could really relate to her blog launching experience. The first day she gets a comment she’s so excited, only to see it’s from her mom. Weeks go by with no comments and she wonders if anyone other than her mom and her husband read her blog. (Reminds me of me!) The day she gets 10 comments and half of them are from people she doesn’t know, she’s super excited. When her readers start sending her photos, recipes and words of encouragement, she’s in disbelief and ecstatic.  Starting a blog is hard! Watching Julie and Julia has inspired me to hang in there and keep posting! Still, if you’re reading this and feel like commenting, please do. I’d love to hear from you and it would really make my day. Thank you for the moral support!

9 Responses to “Julie and Julia: What Julia Child Has to Teach Women Students Today and What Julie Had to Teach Me”

  1. Angela C Bryant  on November 3rd, 2010

    Great insight on the movie! I was one of the first woman Navywide with the particular job that I did in the early 90’s and saw this happening- and still today as well.

    SO how about that, more than a year later and you are still getting comments on this!

  2. Dianna Smith  on September 25th, 2010

    Madeline Albright said it brilliantly, “There’s a place in Hell reserved for women who don’t help other women”.

    Interestingly, see what the Irreverent Sales Girl has to say on this exact topic!

    Facebook: The Irreverent Sales Girl — View Discussions.


  3. Kelly Jenkins-Pultz  on March 25th, 2010

    Hi Donna, I went on your website for the first time today in a long time and love both your blog and talking animation! I’ve referred many people to IWITTS over the years and am hopeful that your resources will begin resonating with those interested in the green economy. Best wishes for continued success. Kelly Jenkins-Pultz, Women’s Bureau, Region 9

  4. jewelbythebay  on September 10th, 2009

    Yes, I recently saw the movie and was inspired – almost – to learn to cook! I noted several aha moments in the story; woman in a man’s profession, size discrimination (heighth or weight), and previous careers (OSS to diplomatic corps in the era of McCarthy). I REALLY identified with Julie when the chicken flew all over the floor!

    So, we know that X/O stereotypes occur. How do we change our personal perceptions in order to avoid these in our own business careers?


  5. Mrs. Burgess  on September 10th, 2009

    I saw the movie too, and was inspired by the work ethics of both women. This movie could also be used to teach the professional skills unit in Early Childhood I.
    Martha Burgess
    Union County Public Schools

  6. mcauly  on August 27th, 2009

    It’s great to finally put a name to the actions of ‘tokenism’… I’ve experienced this a lot and been amazed at how easy it is for women to pull each other down without realizing it… i would be interested in hearing any strategies for dealing with this in the workplace…

  7. Charlene  on August 26th, 2009

    Thanks for the note about Julie and Julia. I love seeing lessons like that in an entertaining format. I am not familiar with “The Tale of X and O”. How can I watch it?

  8. Cherrie McBratney  on August 25th, 2009

    Thank you so much for sharing. You made me think about women who practice the phenomenon of “tokenism”. I have experienced it… new what was going on, just did not know how to deal with it professionally. In education professions, I see it practiced a great deal by women who have reached high ranks, but treat other women who are working towards the same with distain and throw up those road blocks.

    Thank you for making your comments so relevent to today. I have wanted to go and see Julie and Julia, now its on my Hot List.

    Enjoyed reading your Blog.

    Cherrie McBrantey
    TSTC College Reg. Admissions Advisor

  9. annb  on August 25th, 2009

    Wow. Great post. It certainly is difficult to discuss and acknowledge the challenges we have had with tokenism. Keep up the thought provoking and relevant work!

Leave a Reply

Subscribe without commenting